DRAGENwiki · Article

Experimental analysis of behavior (EAB)

Sources checked. Clinical review pending.

The experimental analysis of behavior, or EAB, is the basic laboratory science of behavior analysis. It asks how behavior changes when conditions change, usually by following one organism closely over time. Reinforcement, extinction and stimulus control were firmly established there before applied behavior analysis carried them into daily life.

EAB in 60 seconds

  • Basic and applied differ by the question, not the method. Applied research gets its label from "the interest which society shows in the problems being studied," not from its procedures. [3] Pure basic research seeks fundamental knowledge as an end in itself. [6]
  • It grew from B. F. Skinner's laboratory. Skinner "founded both radical behaviorism and behavior analysis," and he spent his research career almost entirely in the lab. [4][6]
  • Rate of response is the classic measure. The lab sets up a situation in which "a response may be freely repeated," then tracks how often it happens over time. [2][4]
  • It follows one learner at a time. Skinner argued that averaging curves across many trials or learners "will not solve this problem" of tracing how a response changes over time. [2]
  • Two journals mark the two sides. The Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior began in 1958, and the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis in 1968. [1][6]

Jump to: What EAB is · Where it came from · The laboratory's tools · One learner at a time · Basic and applied · From the lab to daily life · A split and a reunion · Debates today · At home and school · Example · Myths · Words to know · Need a PDF? · More from DRAGEN · What remains unknown · Sources

What EAB is

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy lists several names for the family of ideas that grew from Skinner's work: "the experimental analysis of behavior", "behavior analysis", "functional analysis" and "radical behaviorism". [1] Some of these names became the titles of behaviorism's leading societies and journals. [1]

In plain terms, EAB is the part of behavior analysis that works in the laboratory. A researcher sets up a controlled situation, changes one condition at a time, and watches what happens to behavior. The goal is to find general principles: how behavior is learned, kept going, changed and lost.

Mace and Critchfield, two behavior analysts writing in the field's basic journal, describe EAB as having developed mainly as "pure basic" science. [6] Pure basic research, in their description, seeks fundamental knowledge as an end in itself, a goal valued since at least classical Greece. [6] That does not mean basic researchers ignore the world. Skinner himself, they note, celebrated the everyday relevance of laboratory principles. [6] It means the question comes first from the science, not from a particular person's problem.

Much of this work has been done with animals. In his 1950 paper, Skinner described several types of curves "consistently obtained from rats and pigeons." [2] Mace and Critchfield call animal laboratories "historically the field's empirical crucible." [6] A crucible is a container for heating metal. Here it means the place where the field's findings were first tested under pressure.

EAB is not only about animals, though. The first laboratories for the experimental analysis of human behavior were set up in the 1950s and 1960s, though some produced little published research. [6] For a time, only a few pioneers tested whether lab staples such as aversive control and simple schedules of reinforcement held for people. [6] A sizeable community of human laboratory researchers emerged only in the 1980s. [6] Their work extended animal-based principles to people, including the matching relation, which describes how choices are divided between options that pay off at different rates, and delay discounting, the way a reward loses value the longer someone must wait for it. [6]

Why study behavior in a lab at all? Mace and Critchfield quote Skinner's 1938 book on this point. In his view, the importance of a science of behavior comes largely from the possibility of "an eventual extension to human affairs." [6]

Where it came from

EAB starts with B. F. Skinner. The behavior analyst William Baum writes that Skinner "founded both radical behaviorism and behavior analysis." [4] Baum lists Skinner's innovations, among them "a versatile preparation for studying behavior," "response rate as a datum" and "the concept of stimulus control." [4] A preparation, here, is a standard lab setup that many researchers can use. A datum is a single piece of data, the thing that gets measured.

Skinner's own research career was almost entirely laboratory work. [6] Mace and Critchfield suggest that in this way, perhaps without meaning to, he set the tone for EAB as a basic science. [6]

The early years were hopeful. Mace and Critchfield write that a reader of the field's basic journal in its first 15 years would have seen many reasons for optimism. [6] EAB had a home in many universities, including some of the world's leading ones, and research funding came from several sources. Subscriptions were rising, and the journal was an early leader in citation impact factor. [6] A citation impact factor is a measure of how often other researchers cite a journal's papers. In some quarters, EAB was seen as revealing principles that would set the foundation for "addressing the world's great problems." [6]

Skinner himself became known far outside the laboratory. Mace and Critchfield note, citing a 2002 paper, that he went on to become the "Most Eminent Psychologist of the 20th Century." [6] Much of his career went to explaining how laboratory principles bear on everyday concerns, in works published in 1953, 1957 and 1971. [6]

In the final stage of his career, his attention shifted from extending laboratory principles toward critiquing other theories in psychology. [6] Mace and Critchfield write that EAB's difficult times began at roughly the same point. [6] His death cost EAB its strongest advocate, and in their view no one since has matched the broad credibility he brought to basic behavior science. [6]

Two journals gave the science a home. The Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior (JEAB) began in 1958. [1] The Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis (JABA) was founded in 1968. [1][6]

The laboratory's tools

Skinner described the classic method in a 1950 paper. The researcher arranges "a situation in which a response may be freely repeated." [2] The response is chosen because it "may be easily observed and counted," for example touching or pressing a small lever or key. [2] In his pigeon work, the bird "is conditioned to peck at a recessed disc in one wall." [2]

The main measure is rate: how many responses happen in a given amount of time. Skinner recorded responses as "a cumulative curve from which rate of responding is immediately read as slope." [2] Picture a line that steps up a little with every response and never goes down. When responding is fast, the line climbs steeply. When responding stops, the line goes flat. Reading the steepness of the line tells you the rate.

Skinner gave several reasons for trusting rate as a measure:

  • It moves with learning. "As the organism learns, the rate rises." [2] When a response is no longer reinforced, a process called extinction, the rate falls. [2]
  • It is sensitive. The rate responds to changes in motivation, and to events people describe as emotional. [2]
  • It has a wide range. Rates can differ by as much as roughly a thousand to one. [2]
  • It can be steady. He reported pigeons keeping up four or five thousand responses an hour, without a break, for as long as fifteen hours. [2]

Baum, writing six decades later, still counts "response rate as a datum" among Skinner's lasting contributions. [4]

Rate also solved a problem that older methods had. Counting right versus wrong answers, Skinner argued, "cannot yield a continuously changing measure" within a single experiment on a single organism. [2] Rate can. That leads to EAB's best-known habit.

One learner at a time

Skinner did not think averaging was the answer. "Averaging curves for groups of trials or organisms will not solve this problem," he wrote. [2] The point where one response overtakes another, he explained, cannot show the whole history of the change. [2] Rate, he reported, changes smoothly enough in one animal that there is no need to average cases. [2] An orderly pattern can be seen in a single learner.

Jay Moore, writing from the standpoint of a radical behaviorist, puts the same point sharply: "Group statistical designs in which data are aggregated may only obscure, rather than reveal, order." [5] To aggregate data is to pool many people's results into one number, such as an average.

When Baer, Wolf and Risley described applied behavior analysis in the first issue of JABA, they started from this tradition. "The analysis of individual behavior is a problem in scientific demonstration," they wrote. [3] They described it as reasonably well understood, thoroughly described, and already well practised in JEAB. [3]

This is why behavior analysts usually compare a person with their own earlier behavior, not with an average of other people. A graph shows one person's data over days or weeks, and a change in conditions is judged by what happens to that person's line. The DRAGENwiki page on reading a behavior graph shows how to read one.

Basic and applied

What makes research "applied"? Baer, Wolf and Risley answered in 1968. The label "is not determined by the research procedures used," they wrote, but by "the interest which society shows in the problems being studied." [3] Applied researchers choose behaviors because they matter to people and society, rather than because they matter to a theory. [3]

They gave an example. A non-applied researcher "may study eating behavior, for example, because it relates directly to metabolism." [3] An applied researcher studies eating because some children eat too little and some adults eat too much, and studies it in those very people, not in whoever is easiest to study. [3] The behavior is the same. The reason for studying it, and the people studied, differ.

Mace and Critchfield see risks at both ends. Pure basic science can lose touch with the natural world it is supposed to explain. [6] Pure applied work can lose touch with the fundamental processes "that shape the world it is supposed to improve." [6] In their view, neither extreme commands broad support from scholars or material support from society. [6] They argue that research can do better by combining basic and applied questions, literatures and methods. [6]

Their name for that kind of work is translational research. In their description, it breaks new ground by caring about basic principles and everyday problems at the same time. [6] They add that there is "no single recipe" for doing it. [6]

Work in the middle has a cost. Mace and Critchfield cite a 1982 paper by Hake, who complained that translational studies may please no one. They can be "too basic" for applied researchers or practitioners, and "too applied" for basic researchers. [6]

From the lab to daily life

The move from lab to people happened in a particular setting. In the 1950s, psychoanalysis was the main approach to psychotherapy. [6] It did little for two groups of psychiatric patients: people with chronic mental illness, and people with moderate to profound intellectual disabilities. [6] Most lived in institutions where much of the environment could be controlled, and no effective treatments existed for them. [6] So the first translations of laboratory principles focused on these two groups. [6]

DRAGEN describes this history; it does not hold it up as a model. Today's practice centers the person's choices and assent.

Moving from the lab to people meant changing almost everything about the setup. Mace and Critchfield name four main changes: [6]

  1. From animals to people. Lab animals had limited genetic variation and known learning histories. People vary widely in their genes, may have had unknown injuries to the developing nervous system, and bring long learning histories no one fully knows.
  2. From machines to people delivering consequences. In the lab, consequences were uniform and automated. In daily life, they vary and are delivered by people.
  3. From controlled motivation to real life. The lab could control motivation almost completely, for example through food deprivation. In psychiatric settings, there was little control over other sources of reinforcement.
  4. From automatic recording to human observers. Machines no longer counted responses. People did, which brought the risk of measurement error. [6]

"Clearly, success was dependent on laboratory-derived principles being robust," they write. [6] Robust here means the effects had to hold up in messier conditions. The first principles taken out of the lab had been firmly established in basic research: positive and negative reinforcement, positive and negative punishment, extinction, satiation and stimulus control. [6]

Naming these principles is history, not advice. Which procedures are acceptable today is a clinical and ethical question for a BCBA, the family and, above all, the person.

One early example: in 1956, Lindsley tried a variety of presumed reinforcers, such as religious pictures, auditory feedback and music, with patients diagnosed with chronic schizophrenia, with mixed success. [6] Later researchers used food to try to get more consistent effects. [6]

JABA was founded in 1968. [6] In its first issue, Baer, Wolf and Risley argued that describing an applied procedure in terms of its basic principles shows readers "how similar procedures may be derived from basic principles." [3] That, they wrote, can make a body of technology "a discipline rather than a collection of tricks." [3]

A split and a reunion

Baer, Wolf and Risley also defined what counted as an analysis. An analysis, they explained, requires a believable demonstration of the events that make a behavior happen or not happen. [3] An experimenter "has achieved an analysis of a behavior when he can exercise control over it." [3] Mace and Critchfield grant that it is impossible to know for sure, but they argue that this definition helped give early ABA its strong technological focus, meaning a focus on techniques that worked. [6]

Just ten years after JABA began, concerns about too much focus on technology emerged. [6] Deitz, in 1978, was among the first to describe ABA as separating from its scientific roots. Deitz saw a clear shift away from analyzing the contingencies that control behavior, toward making intervention outcomes the priority. [6]

Others measured the drift. In 1980, Hayes and colleagues rated every empirical article in JABA's first 10 volumes. [6] They found a sharp drop in component analyses, studies that take a treatment apart to see which pieces do the work. These fell from an average of 22.3% of articles in the first four volumes to 5.5% in the last four. [6]

Pierce and Epling, also in 1980, described the trend as a divorce of ABA from EAB and urged the two to reconcile. [6] In volume 11 of JABA, they found low rates of reference to basic behavioral processes (25%), citation of EAB sources (11.4%) and use of basic process terms as descriptors (24.6%). [6]

Not everyone saw a problem. In his 1981 presidential address to the Association for Behavior Analysis, Baer defended ABA's emphasis on technology over science. [6] He pointed to a skilled photographer and an effective emergency room physician, neither of whom knew the basic science of their craft. [6] Applied behavior analysts, he said, "have very little need to apply the newest basic findings." [6] In Mace and Critchfield's summary, he held that the vast majority of human behavior problems could be solved through skillful use of positive reinforcement. He also recognized that putting even positive reinforcement alone into practice in the real world is very hard, and varies from one situation to the next. [6]

Then, in Mace and Critchfield's words, "ABA changed abruptly in the mid-1980s." [6] New procedures, known together as functional analysis methods, let researchers identify the contingencies that keep a behavior going. [6] They used that information to build replacement behaviors that serve the same function. [6] Once applied behavior analysts studied behavior this way, EAB research became relevant to their work. [6] Before long, JABA's editors began encouraging explicit links to basic research. [6]

The two sides moved closer again. During part of the 1990s, JABA reprinted summaries of selected JEAB articles. [6] Around the same time, editor Nancy Neef set up a regular series of translational essays, beginning in 1993, on what basic research in JEAB meant for practice. [6] Two JABA special issues on the theme of translation appeared, in 1994 and 2003. [6] DRAGEN's lesson on the four functions of behavior builds on this work.

Debates today

Is EAB losing ground? Mace and Critchfield argued in 2010 that "EAB has seen both its scholarly and societal influence wane." [6] JEAB's paid circulation had fallen to about a third of its historical peak. [6] From 1998 to 2008, its impact factor ranked, on average, near the middle of experimental psychology journals (the 47th percentile). [6] In some circles, they write, this modest citation record hurts the hiring and advancement of EAB researchers and the funding of their departments. [6] They add, while noting that no statistics were available, that EAB's institutional base appeared to be crumbling: basic researchers were not being replaced when they left, and animal laboratories were closing as their faculty retired or as institutions judged them too costly to keep. [6]

Does the wider world notice? When the National Research Council of the National Academy of Sciences asked a panel to review the science of learning and its relevance to education, the resulting book "contained not a single reference to the basic operant learning literature," unless one counts a 1943 work by Hull. [6] Mace and Critchfield argue that EAB's fortunes depend on whether a broad audience, including nonscientists and scientists outside the field, "perceives it as relevant to important human affairs." [6] That audience, in their view, shapes research funding and academic jobs. [6]

Can basic scientists explain their work? Mace and Critchfield cite reviews showing that "good science at best only sometimes leads to practical benefits." [6] Technology often moves ahead without waiting for basic insights. Under normal conditions, they write, pure basic research is "neither necessary nor sufficient" for practical progress, though it can spark it. [6] Communication is part of the problem. When basic scientists are never pushed to think about the everyday relevance of their work, they may not learn to explain why it matters in practice. [6] Often only a few specialists can understand the original research reports. [6]

How far can interpretation go? In his 1953, 1957 and 1971 works, Skinner extended laboratory principles to topics that no experiment had yet studied. [6] Mace and Critchfield call this approach "narrative speculation" about the everyday relevance of lab principles. [6] They grant that it has stirred the imaginations of many behavior analysts. But they say such interpretations have real weaknesses when it comes to the rules of evidence for judging whether they are true. [6]

Do lab findings hold in people? Not always. Some benchmark effects in animal research, such as the response patterns seen on fixed schedules of reinforcement, "have not been reliably reproduced in humans." [6] Other lab principles have simply not been tested in people. [6] And across three translational strategies started by basic researchers, the most common result has been "only scattered efforts, often of limited scope and influence." [6]

What is the way forward? Mace and Critchfield note that progress has often been held back by a functional separation of basic and applied communities. [6] Their answer is collaboration: "innovation is most likely when individuals with basic and applied expertise collaborate." [6]

Did Skinner get everything right? Baum, an admirer, says plainly: "Skinner also made some mistakes." Later radical behaviorist thinking has tried to fix them. [4]

What it means at home and school

Most families and teachers never hear the words "experimental analysis of behavior." But several of its habits show up in good everyday practice.

Counting how often. Rate is simple: count the behavior, then divide by the time you watched. Three requests in 10 minutes is 0.3 per minute. Rate lets you compare a short observation with a long one fairly. DRAGEN's lesson on counting behavior shows how.

Comparing a person with themselves. EAB taught behavior analysts to look at one person's data over time. A child's graph is compared with that same child's earlier days, not with other children. DRAGEN's lesson on reading a behavior graph walks through it.

Principles, not tricks. A strategy works for reasons. When the team knows the reason, it can adjust when something stops working, instead of hunting for a new trick. That is what Baer, Wolf and Risley meant by "a discipline rather than a collection of tricks." [3]

Finding out why before changing what. Functional analysis made basic research relevant to practice by showing what keeps a behavior going. [6]

Lab findings guide; they do not decide. Some lab effects have not held up reliably in people, and others have never been tested with people. [6] A person is not a lab animal. Their preferences, history and words matter.

In DRAGEN's practice, this looks like:

  • Describe behavior in words that two people could check, and count it the same way each time.
  • Read a learner's graph against their own earlier data, not against other children.
  • Treat "no," a complaint, a question or a request to stop as information about what the person needs. It is not "noncompliance," and it is never a target to reduce. See the right to say no.
  • Keep immediate safety separate. If someone could get hurt, deal with safety first, then look at the pattern.
  • Do not explain behavior with a label from inside ("lazy," "manipulative," "unmotivated"). Look at what happens before and after, and at the person's history.
  • Lab findings guide a plan; they do not replace the person. What the person wants, and how they respond, comes first.
  • A BCBA reviews every clinical decision. This page is general information, not medical or clinical advice.

A made-up example

This example is invented. It does not describe a real person.

Learner D is 6. During afternoon play, lids on containers and zippers on bags often stop him. He pulls at them for a moment, then walks away from the toy. His family wants him to have an easy way to ask for help, and he likes the toys inside.

  1. Count it as a rate. For one week, an adult counts how many times Learner D asks for help, in any form (a word, a sign, or handing the item over), during a 20-minute play period. Most days, it is about 2 asks, or 0.1 per minute.
  2. Graph only his own data. Each day goes on one line graph. The team compares Learner D with his own earlier days, not with other children.
  3. Change one thing at a time. A "help" card goes within easy reach, and adults respond quickly every time he asks, with the card or any other way. Over two weeks, his rate of asking climbs to about 0.4 per minute.
  4. His choices count. On two days, he says "no puzzle" and pushes the puzzle box away. The adult writes this down as a choice, offers another toy, and does not count it as a problem. It tells the team what he wants.
  5. Check the setting first. If the rate stops rising, the team looks at the situation before anything else. Are the toys too hard to open? Is help coming fast enough? They do not decide he is being "stubborn."
  6. A BCBA reviews the graph and the plan with the family.

The steps borrow from EAB: count a rate, follow one person over time, change one condition at a time. But the goal came from the family and from Learner D, and his "no" shaped the plan.

Common myths

  • "EAB is only about rats and pigeons." Animal labs were central, but laboratories for human behavior date back to the 1950s and 1960s. [6]
  • "Basic research has nothing to do with real life." The principles ABA first used outside the lab had been firmly established in basic research. [6]
  • "Applied research uses different methods." Baer, Wolf and Risley wrote that research procedures do not decide whether work is applied. Society's interest in the problem does. [3]
  • "Skinner only cared about the lab." Much of his career went to explaining how lab principles bear on everyday concerns. [6]
  • "Every lab finding works the same way in people." Some well-known lab effects have not been reliably repeated in people. [6]

Words to know

  • Experimental analysis of behavior (EAB): the basic laboratory science of behavior analysis. [1][6]
  • Basic research: research that seeks fundamental knowledge as an end in itself. [6]
  • Applied research: research on behavior chosen for its importance to people and society. [3]
  • Translational research: research that connects fundamental principles with everyday problems. [6]
  • Rate of response: how many times a response happens in a given amount of time. [2][4]
  • Cumulative record: a running total of responses over time, in which the rate is read from the steepness of the line. [2]
  • JEAB: the Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, begun in 1958. [1]
  • JABA: the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, founded in 1968. [1][6]
  • Functional analysis: methods for finding which contingencies keep a behavior going, developed in the mid-1980s. [6]

Need a PDF?

Create it here, for free: the DRAGEN app. Use it at your next session.

Or print one we already made, also free:

More from DRAGEN

Related DRAGENwiki pages: behaviorism · radical behaviorism · methodological behaviorism · applied behavior analysis · reading a behavior graph · measuring behavior · four-term contingency · motivating operations · the right to say no · cumulative record · B. F. Skinner · history of ABA

What remains unknown

  • How to make basic research visible and useful to a broad audience is still an open problem. [6]
  • Which laboratory effects hold in people, and under what conditions, is still being worked out. [6]
  • How best to bring basic and applied researchers together is still debated. [6]
  • How much weight to give interpretations that apply lab principles to daily life, without new experiments, is unsettled. [6]
  • This page summarizes the main lines. It does not settle these debates.
  • Last checked on November 12, 2026.

Sources

  1. Graham, G. (2023). Behaviorism. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (first published May 26, 2000; substantive revision January 13, 2023). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/behaviorism/
  2. Skinner, B. F. (1950). Are theories of learning necessary? Psychological Review, 57, 193–216. Classics in the History of Psychology, York University. https://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Skinner/Theories/
  3. Baer, D. M., Wolf, M. M., & Risley, T. R. (1968). Some current dimensions of applied behavior analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 1(1), 91–97. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1310980/
  4. Baum, W. M. (2011). What is radical behaviorism? A review of Jay Moore's Conceptual foundations of radical behaviorism. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 95(1), 119–126. https://doi.org/10.1901/jeab.2011.95-119 (full text: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3014776/)
  5. Moore, J. (2013). Methodological behaviorism from the standpoint of a radical behaviorist. The Behavior Analyst, 36(2), 197–208. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03392306 (full text: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5147434/)
  6. Mace, F. C., & Critchfield, T. S. (2010). Translational research in behavior analysis: Historical traditions and imperative for the future. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 93(3), 293–312. https://doi.org/10.1901/jeab.2010.93-293 (full text: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2861871/)

Pages that link here